Let’s not sugarcoat it: last season was a trainwreck.
Daniel Jones, still fresh off a four-year, $160 million deal, started the year like a guy clinging to a job he knew he was losing. He was ineffective, slow in processing, and eventually injured—again. By midseason, the Giants had seen enough and released him outright, eating a massive financial loss to reset. From bringing us back to the promise land to making the Giants look foolish, it was quite a ride, but I'll always remember Danny Dimes.
In his absence, Tommy DeVito, the lovable undrafted Italian Stallion from 2023, got the first crack at QB1. But this wasn’t Goodfellas—it was Gigli. DeVito struggled mightily, and eventually, the team turned to Drew Lock, the QB2 who should’ve been QB1 from the start. Ironically, Lock ended up being the best quarterback on the roster—which is saying something and also says everything. In Week 18, he torched the Colts for five total touchdowns in a 45-point explosion that felt more like a parody than a win. As fun as that was, it completely nuked the Giants’ draft position, nearly dropping them out of the top three. It was the most Drew Lock thing ever—just enough chaos to remind you he’s in the room.
Instead of diving headfirst into the rookie pool, Joe Schoen and Brian Daboll went with quantity and experience. After attempting to trade for Matthew Stafford, considering Aaron Rodgers, and showcasing to the league that you are in it to compete - Your Giants’ 2025 Quarterback Room is definitely something.
Russell Wilson signed a one-year deal after a bizarre 2024 stint in Pittsburgh. He started hot (6-1), cooled off, and then got bounced from the playoffs by Lamar Jackson. He’s here on a $10.5 million prove-it deal, hoping to rekindle a fraction of his Seattle success in the Meadowlands.
Jameis Winston came over from Cleveland on a two-year, $8 million deal. He saw limited snaps with the Browns but spoke openly about how the Giants offered a “window of opportunity” and a chance to reset the narrative. He’s got the arm, the energy, and the unpredictability. You just never know which Jameis is showing up.
Tommy DeVito was re-signed for backup duty and vibes. He’s beloved by fans, but the organization sees him as QB3.
This might be the wildest quarterback room ever assembled. It may not be the long-term answer, but it will sure be fun. I was fully expecting Jameis to be throwing for 5000 yards with 50 interceptions, but who knows who will start (probably Russ). They’re high-floor, low-ceiling options meant to stabilize the locker room while the franchise figures out who their next real quarterback is.
If you’re going by experience and upside, it’s Wilson’s job to lose. He looked sharper than expected in Pittsburgh, and he still has the deep ball touch that made him a perennial Pro Bowler. Jameis offers a spark and arguably more arm talent, but he’s never put together a full, consistent season.
And DeVito? He’s a great story, but let’s not pretend he’s ready to lead a playoff team.
Let’s just say the reaction to Wilson and Winston was… lukewarm. Most fans wanted a full reset. Instead, they got two guys on short-term deals and a coaching staff clearly hedging their bets.
Analysts have called it a “bridge year,” while others are skeptical the Giants have a real plan. ESPN and CBS both questioned whether either vet moves the needle. And, understandably, a portion of the fanbase sees this as treading water rather than turning the page.
With the No. 3 overall pick, the Giants are in a prime position to draft a quarterback. But reports suggest GM Joe Schoen may go with the best available player, not necessarily a QB. I am okay with this because, although Cam Ward had his moments, I wasn't sold. If it was a quarterback worthwhile, we would've done everything possible last season to get him (however, having Malik Nabers is worth it).
If somehow Ward is available, it seems to be the move. Gut instinct, you take Travis Hunter, and bring excitement to Meadowlands. Although Shedeur Sanders will likely be available, I don't think he's the guy at three. However... if Schoen pulls out a "Draft Day" stunt and gets back into the first round, I would be entertained. He's got a big arm and an NFL pedigree, but he will come with massive media attention and questions about his transition from the Colorado offense.
Other mid-round targets could be in play (if that is still a priority with the QB room they have assembled). Jaxson Dart, the gunslinger with tools out of Ole Miss, could develop under the right coaching. Jalen Milroe, an athletic freak from Alabama, is raw but intriguing as a long-term project. Then there is Syracuse's Kyle McCord, the steady pocket passer. Might be more backup than a star, but worth a flyer in Round 3-4.
The 2025 Giants QB room is deeper than last year’s—but that’s not saying much. They’ve replaced chaos with competence, but the ceiling is still limited. Russ is here to prove he’s not cooked. Jameis is here to rewrite the script. Tommy’s here for the T-shirts. But the future? Still to be determined. If Cam Ward isn’t the pick at No. 3, Schoen better hit a home run with whoever he does take—and find a way to land a QB with upside on Day 2. Because if 2025 turns into another quarterback circus? We might finally see MetLife hit full “Fire Everyone” mode by Halloween
コメント